Imam Suhaib Webb published an article on the Credit Crunch, and the possibility of Islamic finance as an alternative by Andrew Booso.
Now I do not doubt that a Galbraithian approach to capitalism – as argued by Stephen Dunn in the Guardian comment pages on 15 October 2008 – would have largely averted the current disaster, by God’s will. However, I would contend that the nature of the beast dictates that the values of Galbraith will, on most occasions, be overthrown by the greed factor inherent in the essential make-up. Thus when Gordon Brown, the Prime Minister of Britain, wants to invoke for the markets the ‘values’ that it cannot generate itself, but which are values of ‘fairness, stewardship [and] cooperation’ derived from those ‘learned in families, neighbourhoods and communities and developed in the relationships we enjoy as a society’ (Telegraph online, 18 October 2008) – then we must question whether our knowledge of these factors supports the notion of capitalism now being refined for the better. Or is this just another of the endless cycles – as outlined by Dunn – that capitalism thrusts upon us from time to time, and we are simply required to bear?
Unsurprisingly, some Islamic-minded economists have set out a more just and stable method of banking within the current system. Nevertheless, the conventional banking system has largely ignored such proposals for numerous reasons, unless it means a piecemeal development of a limited number of products that allow the main actors to gain the wealth of Muslims. The nature of such a scenario means that the tail is truly only ever wagged by the dog, as dictated by the dog.
As-salamu alaikum,
The writer unfortunately falls at the first hurdle. If the whole world drinks whisky do we need to find an ‘Islamic’ type of whisky? Patently not, so why is it a sine qua non that we must find a form of ‘Islamic’ banking, for in essence, we are looking for an Islamic form of usury.
Wa’Alaikum as-Salam
pardon my ignorance, but why do you think that a banking system must use usury?
Manas,
I don’t know either what he is talking about.
His homepage looks suspicious.
Anyway, I am going to sleep, good night and As’salamu Aleikum
You need to have Islamic banking because you need to trade and barter with other people, and those transactions need to be halal.
comment edited to make it acceptable- MS
“Ar rijalu …”
I am sorry, but your joke was below the belt. Hence deleted.